
The Butter Battle Book has been under fire for its commentary on nuclear war, on how atomic bombs lead to either a stalemate or total annihilation of the human race. However, for an allegedly propaganda book promoting peace, it spurts enough humor to jolt rocks out of bed, even when discussing victory and defeat. I found out about it when coordinating Banned Books Week at my school in 2008, but only discovered it in my local library last week. If I had known how much a picture book could be, then I would’ve checked it out a long time ago.
Butter concerns two types of civilians: Yooks and Zooks. The Yooks eat their bread with butter side up while the Zooks eat butter side down. Because of this, there’s a great wall between the two groups that becomes the center of a battlefield, where the Zooks stave off the Yooks with every crazy weapon they can come up with.
Dr. Seuss eases what would otherwise develop into pessimistic poetry, however, by describing the plight of the Yooks as the Zooks outmatch them. The ridiculous weapons pale in comparison to nuclear missiles; we have cocker spaniels named Daniel firing orange Kick-a-poo Kids, elephants toting blue boom-blitzes, and pep groupies called the Right-Side-Up Song Girls. How can you not have fun reading the rhymes aloud?
This is the culinary context book of the week because today’s strip concerns the Butter Battle Book, and because the whole conflict in the book starts over a disagreement on how to butter bread. Everyone has had this sort of problem on how to eat or prepare food, especially within families and across international borders. At home I’m constantly chastised for eating while I’m walking, which is a messy habit, but it’s never ruined my dinner.
The Yooks have a point, though, because eating bread with the butter side down is messy, but at the same time such a little issue should never lead to a big blowout. That makes the book all the more entertaining as we watch the Yooks muddle through warfare.
Someone should just go in and ask them all to switch to olive oil for dipping. It’s healthier and has less saturated fat, and can’t be buttered onto bread.